The European Revolutions, 1848 – 1851, was designed
as a textbook for early undergraduate and (optimistically) advanced high school
students. As such, it does not contain intensely complex theory regarding the
events. It is a basic depiction of the occurrences and major players of the
period. Some will find this approach
refreshingly straightforward; a delineation of what happened without the haze
of a historian’s pet theories and self-congratulatory mental gymnastics. Others
will find the work unchallenging.
This is not to say that the portrayal is all action and no
thought, like so many books on military battles. Sperber spends the first half
of his book discussing the pre-revolutionary environment and the causes leading
to the struggles of 1848. Those already familiar with living and working
conditions in Early- to Mid-19th Century Europe, who are reading
primarily to inform themselves about the revolutionary years, will find this
section tedious with no new information; they can skip directly to Chapter
Three, “The Outbreak of Revolution.” These following chapters illustrate the
rise of mass movements with particular attention to the varieties and
structures of rebellious organizations.
Just about every reader of this review has grown-up within a
representative form of democracy. Even those inured to the vicissitudes of
history can find themselves discouraged by a story of flowering republics
crushed under the military boot of autocratic kings. It was a dramatic burst of
freedom and equally quick reversal. But Sperber does an excellent job of
coddling the reader by discussing at length the groundwork laid by this
continent-wide revolt. Post-1848 monarchs, while not required to draft a
constitution, were seen as backward and faced importunate nagging from below if
they did not. Press censorship was no longer a given strategy of conservative
regimes. The process of organizing an opposition had been inculcated. Most
importantly, people became acquainted with and accustomed to democratic
notions. If seen as the first steps in a learning process that culminated,
through persistent dedication, in our current period of widespread republican
government, the bitter pill of this period will be swallowed in a spirit of
more philosophical and sanguine remove.
I cannot say that The European Revolutions, 1848 – 1851
will be the most exhilarating read you’ve ever had (unless the period and
events alone excite you), but it will be appropriately informative and clear.
Sperber, Jonathan. The European Revolutions, 1848 – 1851. Cambridge: The Cambridge University Press, 2003.
For review of a book on prior causes & events resulting in the European Revolutions, see:
http://greatnonfictionbooks.blogspot.com/2014/07/the-age-of-revolution-1789-to-1848-by.html
No comments:
Post a Comment